My manager used AI to write my performance review. Should I even read it?

Dear Chatty,

My manager obviously used AI to write my performance review. It said, “In today’s fast-paced environment, you don’t just meet expectations — you exceed them.” If he couldn’t be bothered to write it himself, should I even bother reading it?

~ Evaluated(ish) in Evanston

Dear Evaluated(ish),

Yes, you should read it for the same reason you’ve read all your past reviews that probably followed a template from HR that hasn’t changed in 10 years. Buried somewhere in that sloppy language are some nuggets about your performance.

Feeling insulted by an AI-written review is fair. But sulking about it won’t get you a raise. Every generic line in that review is an invitation for you to add the specifics your manager left out. So he says you exceeded expectations? Great, now you get to respond with how you renegotiated a vendor contract and created an onboarding guide for new hires.

Your manager didn’t consider how taking his human judgment out of your review would impact you. Your best response is to bring human judgment — your human judgment — back into focus.

~ Chatty

Previous
Previous

AI treats me like a total stranger every day. Is that normal?

Next
Next

Do I have to stop using what works just because AI uses it too?