Dear Chatty,
We used AI to write a job posting and screen applicants. The applicant with the strongest résumé sent an obviously AI-generated cover letter, and it makes him look lazy.
Is it fair to count it against him when we rely on AI so much ourselves?
~ On the Fence in Fairplay
Dear On the Fence,
No, it’s not fair to count the candidate’s AI use against him. But it’s totally fair to use the substance of the cover letter against him.
If the letter feels generic and says more about the position than it does about the candidate, that’s a red flag regardless of who or what wrote it. If it includes specific and verifiable details about the candidate’s fit for the position, but your AI-spidey senses are going crazy, here’s my advice to you: pretend AI doesn’t exist.
Apply your pre-AI cover letter judgment to what’s in front of you right now. If the candidate checks all the boxes to move forward in the process, move him forward. If he doesn’t, don’t. Adding “used AI” to that checklist won’t help you place the right person in the right role.
You trusted AI to find him. Now trust yourself to evaluate him.
~ Chatty